Is Your Budget Easy to Beat? You are Probably Budgeting Wrong!


Image by RambergMediaImages via Flickr

If you are constantly beating your budget, you need to set more challenging goals.

The Smart Family Finance family budget is getting a tweak. For the last two months our family has managed to come in far under budget. It was a lot of hard work too. We cut deep and had to find a number of ways to make up for it, but now that we’ve adjusted and have changed habits, we don’t find it so hard to meet and come in under budget on all categories. Dare I say, we’ve reached that unacceptable point at which it is easy to meet and beat our budget.

This is why I’m rewarding my family with more painful cuts in our budgeted categories. It’s not that I’m a penny pinching tyrant. I also have no problem conceding that following an easy budget is infinitely preferable to no budget at all. However, if you’ve created an easy budget for yourself, you are not really budgeting, you are merely tracking your income and expenses.

What is Wrong With Easy Budgets

There is an overall misconception about what a budget truly is. For many, a budget is about recording income, expenses and then ensuring that you don’t over-spend the money you make.

This misconception leads to what I like to call “The Straw Man Budget.” A straw man budget occurs when you aren’t really being honest about creating financial goals. Instead, all of your budgeted categories are inflated to ensure that you are never over-budget. The problem is that you’ve set the bar so high that it’s more of a challenge coming in over-budget than under-budget. Instead of creating a serious goals that requires effort to overcome, you’ve set up a straw man so that you can knock it down every time without fail.

These types of budgets are not bad. In fact, for some that struggle with apathy in tracking their finances, it may even be motivational. It’s better than nothing, but it’s just not really the purpose of budgeting.

Why Real Budgets are Challenging

A budget is a plan that tracks and helps you reach financial goals. It isn’t supposed to be a passive record, but an active tool that takes you from your current financial condition to an ideal financial condition.

For example, if you live paycheck to paycheck, but want to put away 10 percent of your paycheck for retirement, you’ve just established a financial goal and need to move your finances from point A to point B. Your next step is to build a budget and a plan to get you to that financial goal. Perhaps you cut back on spending so that you can pay down debt or maybe you just need to cut back on eating out. Your budget is the tool you use to plan and track your money so that you are now able to save 10 percent of your income.

Perhaps you aren’t dealing with such an obvious financial obstacle, but I’m certain you can come up with any number of financial goals. Have you ever wanted to take a trip to Europe? Retire young? Invest in entrepreneurial ventures? These are all aspirations that can lead to goal setting and the best way to achieve these goals is by planning and tracking through a budget.

How to Avoid an Easy Budget

If you consistently come in under budget, there are only two potential explanations. Either you are cheating on your aspirations and goals by hoarding your money instead of spending, or you need to come up with more goals or new goals.

I’ve already discussed cash hoarding, which is when you refuse to spend money in areas and opportunities that you really shouldn’t be passing up. The solution is to accept the fact that a budget is as much about spending what you say you will spend as it is saving what you plan on saving.

The other easy budget symptom is a failure to reassess your goals. As I said, a budget is a tool that moves you from one financial state to another. Once you’ve found that your budget has become easy, it’s safe to say that you are at your new financial condition. Of course, holding your current financial state could be a legitimate goal, but if you were to be honest with yourself, I’m sure there are a number of other lofty goals. For example, you could start a college fund for your children, donate more to charity or set up an inheritance fund for your grandchildren.

When you reach a goal, try and come up with new goals. It might take some practice at first, but there are nearly limitless possibilities.

Budgets Should be Challenging, Not Necessarily Hard

It’s important to draw a distinction between easy, challenging and hard budgets. Easy is where you set the budgeting bar so high it’s more difficult to go over budget than under budget. Moving from one financial state to another financial state will by definition require effort and thus a challenge. However, you don’t have to force yourself to budget so that it is difficult.

Difficult budgets are where you make major life changes and begin eating Mac N’ Cheese four times a week. You use difficult budgets in times of financial necessity like the loss of a job or paying down your debt. The minimal requirement for a challenging budget is movement. So long as you set goals that move you to a new financial ground, you are doing a marvelous job.

It’s not that easy budgets are bad, but they don’t truly qualify as a budget.

Read More About Effective Budgeting:

Enhanced by Zemanta
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

8 comments for “Is Your Budget Easy to Beat? You are Probably Budgeting Wrong!

  1. November 10, 2011 at 11:35 pm

    We had to adjust a few categories on our budget last month because we were consistently coming in under budget. Like you said, an inflated category does you no good. It’s much better to allocate that to achieving a financial goal.

    • Shaun Fowler
      November 11, 2011 at 1:59 am

      agreed. There’s something to avoiding overspending, but you might as well put all that tracking to some use.

  2. November 11, 2011 at 12:50 am

    Wow – impressive. Way to be proactive! Also, welcome back!

    • Shaun Fowler
      November 11, 2011 at 2:00 am

      Thanks Corey. I can’t wait to share some pictures. We stayed on an amazing house with a ridge-line view. I wish we could have spent a month there.

  3. November 11, 2011 at 12:53 pm

    Shaun thanks for linking back. Although its your own article, it adds juice to my blog :) again an excellent round up you put together.

    • Shaun Fowler
      November 12, 2011 at 1:59 am

      Those are the best kinds of links. I can link to you and myself at the same time :)

  4. November 25, 2011 at 11:33 pm

    Back in the bad old days, the biggest weakness to my budget was me. I failed my budget as much as the other way around until I took myself out of the picture to some degree by automating part of the process.

    After setting up my budget I set up automatic money transfers into sub-accounts, each of which was designated for a certain category of expense. I have a groceries account, rent/mortgage, utilities, fun money, short-term savings, car, etc. It’s basically an envelopes system.

    Setting this up as an automated process changed everything for me because now, instead of worrying about paying bills I was focused on paying myself. I never had to worry about whether or not I had funds set aside to pay bills, etc. I knew there was money for it because I had set it aside right from the start.

    The biggest adjustment was in taking fun money from my personal fun money account instead of our main checking account. But even that really wasn’t hard at all.

    I really had to take myself out of the budgeting picture. I needed a system that worked and then I just needed to follow it. Once I got myself set up that way, my budget really worked, as it has for several years now. And I can say without any doubt that it has helped me financially as much, if not more than anything else I’ve done.

    As you pointed out, having goals for spending is really critical. It sets your mental state around spending and gives you a context for motivating yourself, which I think is absolutely critical to changing behavior.

    Great post Shaun. Thanks for writing it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *